Roofers in Gary, IN

4 checked roofers, why we picked each one, and what the job should cost. Last checked November 2026.

Typical cost

$6,000–$14,000

Large, steep or premium-material roof

$16,000+

Roofers checked

4

The shortlist

  1. Edwin’s Roofing and Gutters PLLC

    Central Gary roofing contractor on Broadway.

    2247 Broadway, Gary, IN

    Typical cost $6,000–$14,000
  2. Turnak Roofing, Inc.

    Glen Park-area Gary roofing contractor on Georgia St.

    4036 Georgia St, Gary, IN

    Typical cost $6,000–$14,000
  3. Babilla Roofing

    Glen Park-area Gary roofing contractor on Harrison St.

    3974 Harrison St, Gary, IN

    Typical cost $6,000–$14,000
  4. JT Roofers Co

    Lake Station roofing contractor on Central Ave just east of Gary.

    2000 Central Ave, Lake Station, IN

    Typical cost $6,000–$14,000

Featured spots are paid placements and are always labeled. Everything else is an editorial pick.

What it should cost in Gary

JobTypical rangeWhat changes the price
Minor roof repair$150–$1,000A few missing shingles, a cracked vent boot or a small flashing fix
Typical roof repair$395–$1,967Size of the damaged area, roof pitch and how easy it is to reach
Major roof repair$1,000–$6,000+Rotted decking, large leaks or storm damage across several areas
Asphalt shingle roof replacement$5,900–$16,000Roof size in squares, pitch, number of layers to tear off and shingle grade

Sources: Angi 2026; HomeGuide 2026; This Old House 2026. Local prices vary, so always get a written quote.

Ask before you book

  • Is the quote a full tear-off or a layover on top of the old shingles?
  • What will you charge per sheet if you find rotted decking under the shingles?
  • Which shingle brand and line are you using, and what warranty comes with it?
  • Is the roofer licensed where required, and can you show proof of insurance?
  • Who handles the permit, cleanup and nail sweep when the job is done?

Red flags

  • A door-to-door crew shows up right after a storm and wants a deposit today.
  • The quote is one number with no line items for tear-off, underlayment or flashing.
  • They offer to cover or waive your insurance deductible.
  • They ask for full payment before any work starts.

How we picked these roofers

1

Real local roofers

Each listing is a roofing business with a street address in or next to the city, taken from Google Maps.

2

Address and phone checked

We copy the address and phone exactly as shown on the business’s Maps profile on the date checked.

3

Price range sourced

Cost ranges come from published 2026 cost guides by Angi, HomeGuide and This Old House.

Details last checked November 15, 2026.

Roofers in Gary: common questions

How much does a new roof cost in Gary?

Published 2026 guides put a typical asphalt shingle roof replacement at about $5,900 to $16,000. Angi lists $5,900 to $12,900 and HomeGuide lists $5,700 to $16,000. Your price depends on roof size, pitch, tear-off and local labor rates, so get written quotes from roofers in Gary.

Should I repair or replace my roof?

Repairs make sense for small, local damage like a few missing shingles or one leak. Angi puts most roof repairs at $395 to $1,967. If the roof is near the end of its life or damage is spread across many areas, replacement often costs less over time.

How long does a roof replacement take?

Many asphalt shingle replacements on an average home take one to three days. Weather, roof size, steep pitch and rotted decking found during tear-off can add time. Ask the roofer for a schedule in writing.

How do I compare roofing quotes?

Ask each roofer to quote the same scope: tear-off, underlayment, flashing, ventilation and the same shingle line. Check that each quote lists the price for replacing bad decking. Compare the warranty terms, not only the total price.

Run a roofing business in Gary? Get on the shortlist.